- Best American Essays 2008
- Patricia Brieschke (memoir), “Cracking Open” (PMS no. 7)
- Best Creative Nonfiction, Vol. 2
- Patricia Brieschke (memoir), “Cracking Open” (PMS no. 7)
- Best Creative Nonfiction, Vol. 1
- Lori Soderlind (memoir), “66 Signs that the Former Student who Invited You to Dinner Is Trying to Seduce You” (PMS no. 5)
- Best American Essays 2007
- Molly Peacock (memoir), “Passion Flowers in Winter” (PMS no. 6)
- Best American Essays 2005
- Holly Welker (memoir), “Satin Worship” (PMS no. 4)
- New Stories from the South
- Ada Long (story), “Clairvoyant” (PMS no. 4)
- Pushcart Prize 2005
- Honorable mention (poem), Honorée Fanonne Jeffers, “What is Written for Me” (PMS no. 3)
- Best American Poetry 2004
- Carly Sachs (poem), “the story” (PMS no. 3)
- Best American Poetry 2003
- Ruth Stone (poem), “Lines” (PMS no. 2)